Wood vs. Vinyl: Which is the Better Option for Replacement Windows?

Wood vs. Vinyl: Which is the Better Option for Replacement Windows?

Choosing the right window for your property demands attention to detail and a willingness to look at all potential options.

Two choices stand out more than others. These are wood and vinyl windows. It’s important to look at what each type of window is all about and why it can be an effective alternative to what you have right now.

Here is a breakdown of how these two windows types compare.

Pros of Wood Windows

A lot of people prefer the timeless and charming look of wood windows. Below, we lay out the benefits of these classic beauties:

Ideal for Colder Climates

If you reside in a colder climate, you will want something that can keep the cool air out. This is easier said than done in some of the coldest regions of the world. This is where wood windows are good because they insulate the heat well.

This ensures nothing comes in or goes out when it comes to the heating. This is great for your heating bill at the end of the month.

Aesthetically Pleasing

The one thing most experts state about wood windows is that they are aesthetically pleasing. They are easy on the eyes and look impressive once they are installed.

It is their rugged, well-built design that makes them appealing. If you want something beautiful then it is likely you are going to lean towards wood windows.

Cons of Wood Windows

There is almost always some drawbacks to even the best of products. Here are some of the cons of wood windows:


The cost associated with wood windows can be a deterrence. You are going to have to pay a little bit more to get a wood window installed compared to other types of windows. This is acceptable when it’s a single window, but becomes challenging when multiple windows are installed on the property.

It’s important to set a budget and be aware of what you are getting into before looking at wood windows.

Requires Regular Maintenance

The maintenance can be challenging for those who are not used to doing it. A lot of property owners have routine maintenance scheduled in because they realize the windows can go bad with time.

They are well-built, but wood has to be maintained due to the nature of the material. Wood can be extremely durable to the elements, but its not impervious. The beauty of the natural look of wood must be maintained or you will find yourself having to replace them sooner than expected.

Pros of Vinyl Windows

The durability and low-maintenance of vinyl windows is what makes this product so popular. Here are some of the pros of choosing this type of window for your home:

Long List of Options

Vinyl windows are ideal for those who want as many options to choose from as possible. There are different types available and you can pinpoint what works best for your needs.

This is valuable when it comes to finding a good fit rather than going with the same type of design as everyone else. With these options, you are going to feel far more in control of what you are getting.


Most people are going to have one eye on their budget and rightly so. This is a sizable investment and that is why many people lean towards vinyl windows. These are windows that are easy to enjoy and come with the perks that you always hope for. If you want something affordable, you are going to enjoy the value of a vinyl window. It is not going to cost as much as other types of windows and can lead to significant savings.

Cons of Vinyl Windows

Like we said above, even the most popular and durable of products can have their disadvantages. The downsides to vinyl windows that they are:

Hard to Paint

Not everything is good with vinyl windows and one of the main issues has to do with painting them. If you are someone that wants to spruce things up a bit, you are going to have a hard time doing it with vinyl windows.

They are not easy to paint at the best of times. You will need to be meticulous and it still isn’t going to turn out the way you want. This is something to account for when installing vinyl windows on your property.

Costly to Customize

Customization is possible, but you are going to have to pay a pretty penny for it. A person that is looking to personalize details associated with the window has to be ready to foot the bill. While these windows are affordable to install, they are not as budget-friendly to personalize.

Comparing Wood vs. Vinyl Windows


This is a subjective element that is mentioned due to how opinion can vary. Wood windows are known for being aesthetically pleasing because of the finishing. They stand out, and can become a focal point for the property.

Vinyl windows are also gorgeous, but can be harder to repaint. Leaving you with less options to easily customize, or update the style of in the future.


Reliability is important and both do well.

Wood windows require extra maintenance, which can be difficult for those who don’t have the time or the funds to dedicate to this part of the home’s upkeep. While vinyl windows demand less, but are not as effective in colder climates. It’s important to determine what works best for your needs.


It’s important to understand the impact of your budget on a choice such as this one.

Wood windows are more expensive up front, which can be taxing on those needing multiple windows at once. They are also expensive to maintain. On the other hand, vinyl windows are cheaper upfront and easier to maintain. The only time they are costly is if you want to personalize them later.

So, What is the Final Verdict? Wood or Vinyl Windows?

In the end, it comes down to what your property demands.

If you are in a colder climate, it’s often better to look at wood windows. However, these windows come with high-maintenance requirements and are expensive upfront. For those on a tight budget, it’s better to go with vinyl windows. However, it will be much harder to customize them once they’re installed.

Weigh the pros and cons of each to decide what works best for you moving forward.

Whether you need help deciding what works best for you, or you already know what you want and just need to find a reliable and trustworthy installer, America’s Best Choice has got your back. Call your nearest location to learn more.

© Copyright 2024 - America's Best Choice | Atlanta Web Design by M16 Marketing - TrustDALE Certified is for Atlanta Dealer only.
Find The Nearest Dealer Free Estimate